Vinyl VS Laminate Planks – Pros and Cons of Each

Published on Friday, July 24th, 2020

Vinyl VS Laminate Planks - Pros and Cons of Each

If you are looking for an affordable, durable flooring option, often vinyl and laminate are the top choices. When you compare vinyl vs laminate planks and the pros and cons of each, it’s important to understand these differences to get the best bang for your buck.

Vinyl vs Laminate Planks – The Pros and Cons of Each

While both laminate vinyl flooring is durable, easy to maintain, and offer a number of different styles, they have their differences.


Vinyl flooring is 100% plastic, giving it superior resistance to moisture. Its water resistance makes vinyl an excellent choice for kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms, and basements. When water sits on vinyl floors, even for an extended period of time, it will not damage the surface. Plus, it’s more resilient and much more comfortable in comparison to tile.

You can install vinyl flooring over many types of flooring as a floating floor. It is very easy to take care of, just be sure to choose a thick wear layer to prevent scrapes and scratches and vacuum occasionally as well as a mop to keep your vinyl flooring looking fantastic. Speaking of looking fantastic, the look of vinyl is rapidly changing for the better. High-end vinyl floors mimic natural materials better than ever before. They offer incredible surface detail to mimic that hardwood look with the feel of distressed or embossed wood.

Vinyl flooring is a great option for those who have homes filled with frequent friends, children, and pets as it is amazingly resistant to scratches and damages.


Since we are comparing vinyl vs laminate planks and the pros and cons of each, it’s quite important to weigh the cons. While vinyl flooring can create the texture of real hardwood, it does not feel like real hardwood in comparison to what laminate flooring offers. Low-quality planks scratch and dent easily, therefore, in order to reap the benefits of vinyl, this can end up running you more than other wood-look options like laminate.

Vinyl flooring is not biodegradable. Also, it can be hard to remove the planks once glued down. Regardless, these cons can be minor to some as the longevity of this floor often outweighs these issues.


Just like vinyl, laminate is a synthetic product that can mimic the look of real hardwood. One major benefit of laminate flooring in the vinyl vs laminate planks and the pros and cons of each debate is the comfortable feel underfoot. Laminate has a thicker composition that includes wood content, which is what makes this flooring material feel soft and warm.

Many homeowners prefer the look of laminate to that of vinyl. While both flooring types come in a variety of styles, colors, and patterns, laminate often provides a more realistic look of hardwood flooring. Homeowners often choose laminate over vinyl for highly visible areas of their homes including entryways, living rooms, and dining rooms.


Often, laminate floors need to be replaced within just 10 years of installation. Because of this, the initial cost of the laminate is much cheaper than the vinyl so you can get fresh flooring for less money. However, be sure to save up for replacement floors if you plan to stay in your home for a long time.

Laminate isn’t quite as waterproof as vinyl flooring. If standing water is left on laminate planks long enough, it will seep through the seams and down into the fiberboard core, destroying your floor.

Vinyl VS Laminate Planks – The Similarities

Vinyl may be a better choice for you if water resistance, lifespan, and durability are your top priority. However, laminate may be preferable if you are looking for a more stylish appearance at a lower cost while being soft underfoot. These flooring materials do have their similarities which may help you in making your decision:

  • Ease of Installation: Both laminate and vinyl come in planks that lock together as a floating floor over almost any type of subfloor. This makes both flooring options an easy DIY installation. However, if you need a foam underlayment for laminate or decide to go with vinyl sheeting, you may need the help of a professional.
  • Ease of Maintenance: Both flooring types are easy to keep clean. Simply mop with a damp mop, vacuum, and sweep as needed. Specialty cleaning products or specific machinery is not needed to keep these floors in good shape.
  • Ecofriendly: Vinyl and laminate flooring have environmentally friendly options available, both offer low emitting material or recycled content.
  • Cost: Depending on the style and features you choose with either flooring, the price is relatively comparable. Both are considered to be very budget-friendly options.

The winner of this comparison is really up to you. Both are strong, beautiful flooring options. For more information on these flooring types, contact one of our professionals by calling (480) 451-9600 or by reaching out here. We look forward to working with you!

About Us

Scottsdale Flooring America has been family owned and operated in the valley for over 20 years. Our team believes in the value of local ownership and deep roots within the community. You will receive expert help finding the perfect flooring in Scottsdale for your home with…

Latest Posts

Contact Info

10250 N
90th St Scottsdale Suite #102,
AZ 85258
Telephone: 480-451-9600